Status quo by asset: Tuesday, November 17, 2026
For each asset group: what the market favours and why, whether that is changing, and the evidence. Back to the 2026-11-17 market moves page.
Status quo by asset
US stocks intact
1. Where we are
Value and dividend payers lead growth: SCHD is up 35.3% over 1Y against 9.3% for QQQ, a lead that narrowed to −2.8 pp in June and was regained, with 48% of it in the last month. State: intact (since 2026-10-07). SCHD's 90-day gap to QQQ is +9.6 pp, up from +7.3 pp at the end of October; the 1Y lead was regained after narrowing to −2.8 pp in June.
Path, 1Y (Value (IWD) vs growth (IWF)): value ahead of growth on 100% of sessions; gap ranged from +0.2 pp (2025-11-19) to +34.6 pp (2026-11-16); largest reversal 11.7 pp, from +26.6 pp on 2026-07-29 to +14.9 pp on 2026-10-07; 0% of the +33.6 pp gap came in the last 1W; 30% of the +33.6 pp gap came in the last 1M. Label: volatile / round-trip.
Path, 1Y (Dividend (SCHD) vs Nasdaq 100 (QQQ)): SCHD ahead of QQQ on 89% of sessions; gap ranged from −2.8 pp (2026-06-18) to +28.1 pp (2026-11-05); largest reversal 25.1 pp, from +22.3 pp on 2026-03-30 to −2.8 pp on 2026-06-18; 4% of the +26.0 pp gap came in the last 1W; 48% of the +26.0 pp gap came in the last 1M. Label: volatile / round-trip.
2. How we got here
- 2026-06-18: SCHD's 1Y lead over QQQ narrowed to −2.8 pp, its low for the year, then was regained. (path of Dividend (SCHD) vs Nasdaq 100 (QQQ))
- 2026-10-07: Value's 1Y lead over growth bottomed at 13.9 pp, then surged. (path of Value (IWD) vs growth (IWF))
- 2026-10-31: October: AI capex doubts drove a rotation out of AI platforms and chips into dividend payers. (what drove October 2026)
- 2026-11-17: Growth beat value by 0.5 pp on the day, but value still leads by 9.4 pp over 1M, a lead rebuilt since early October. (Value (IWD) vs growth (IWF), path of Value (IWD) vs growth (IWF))
Rolling 90-day: SCHD minus QQQ, trailing 90-day gap: Last +9.6 pp, Oct 31 +7.3 pp, Sep 30 −2.7 pp, Aug 31 +12.5 pp, Jul 31 +3.7 pp, Jun 30 −21.4 pp, May 31 −18.7 pp, Apr 30 +0.9 pp, Mar 31 +18.7 pp, Feb 28 +18.1 pp, Jan 31 +13.6 pp, Dec 31 −0.2 pp, Nov 30 −8.9 pp. All 90-day trends
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
Value leads over 1W, 1M, 3M, 6M and 1Y, a lead that narrowed in early October and was regained, mostly in the last month; the pace is accelerating.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
Value's lead is the net effect of AI spending doubts over 1M and of hawkish Fed repricing and the real-yield shock over 6M; a smaller part is residual to the shared forces.
Today's review: reaffirmed. Both assumptions hold: value leads growth by 9.4 pp over 1M and the 2Y is up 120 bp over 1Y; growth's 0.5 pp edge on the day did not reverse the 1W lead. Confidence: medium. Value leads on every horizon from 1W to 1Y, and the Fed and real-yield forces hold at 6M.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- AI spending doubts: steady (Value (IWD) vs growth (IWF))
- Rate and election news beyond the shared forces: gone (CNBC (article), CNBC (article))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). Value leads growth by 0.8 pp over 1W and 9.4 pp over 1M, though growth beat it by 0.5 pp on the day.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Tailwind: Value: AI spending doubts weigh on growth-heavy indexes (Value (IWD) vs growth (IWF))
- Tailwind: Value: Fed rate-increase pricing (US 2Y)
- Tailwind: Value: higher real yields (10Y real yield (Treasury))
Reasoning
Mechanism: markets price Fed rate increases and real yields are higher → cash-generating value and dividend stocks gain relative to long-duration growth → AI spending doubts hit the growth-heavy indexes, widening value's lead in the last month
Key assumptions:
- Value keeps leading growth over 1M: holding
- Rate-increase pricing stays in place: the 2Y yield is above its level a year ago: holding
News vs data:
- Coverage tied the chip slump to doubts about AI spending and to state curbs on new data centres after the midterms. (cited by CNBC (article), Foreign Policy Journal (article), CNBC (article)) What the data shows (partly consistent): The data shows semis 10.7 pp behind the market and tech 15.0 pp behind defensives over 1M, and the fitted AI-doubts force is the strongest 1M force, though the fit explains about a third of the moves.
Sectors intact
1. Where we are
Defensive sectors are favoured over tech: tech (XLK) trails defensives by 15.0 pp over 1M, while staples sit 1.2% and health care 2.3% below their 5-year highs. State: intact (since 2026-10-05). Tech is 19.2% below its 5-year high; its 90-day gap to defensives is −14.9 pp, from −3.7 pp at the end of October.
Path, 1M (Tech (XLK) vs defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU)): defensives ahead of tech on 68% of sessions; gap ranged from −15.7 pp (2026-11-16) to +3.6 pp (2026-10-28); largest reversal 6.5 pp, from −2.9 pp on 2026-10-22 to +3.6 pp on 2026-10-28; 15% of the −15.0 pp gap came in the last 1W. Label: volatile / round-trip.
2. How we got here
- 2026-10-05: Tech's 6M lead over defensives peaked at 13.0 pp, then reversed. (path of Tech (XLK) vs defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU))
- 2026-10-31: October: tech lagged defensives by 18.6 pp on AI capex doubts. (what drove October 2026)
- 2026-11-05: The 1M gap widened after the midterms as the AI trade broke down. (path of Tech (XLK) vs defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU), CNBC (article))
- 2026-11-17: Tech beat defensives by 0.5 pp on the day as all sectors fell, after trailing them by 2.7 pp over the prior two sessions. (Tech (XLK) vs defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU), Tech (XLK))
Rolling 90-day: XLK minus defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU), trailing 90-day gap: Last −14.9 pp, Oct 31 −3.7 pp, Sep 30 +13.3 pp, Aug 31 −11.9 pp, Jul 31 +5.1 pp, Jun 30 +38.2 pp, May 31 +42.7 pp, Apr 30 +9.2 pp, Mar 31 −10.7 pp, Feb 28 −10.4 pp, Jan 31 −9.5 pp, Dec 31 −1.5 pp, Nov 30 +1.7 pp. All 90-day trends
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
The gap holds over 1W, 1M, 3M and 6M and is accelerating over the month, though tech edged ahead on the day.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
Tech's 1M lag is mostly AI spending doubts, the strongest active 1M force; the rest is a residual that coverage ties to data-centre policy after the midterms.
Today's review: reaffirmed. The 1M gap holds at 15.0 pp; tech's 0.5 pp edge on the day came as defensives fell too, so the 1W lag of 2.6 pp stands. Confidence: medium. AI spending doubts are the strongest 1M force and explain most of the gap.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- AI spending doubts: steady (Tech (XLK) vs defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU))
- Data-centre policy risk: steady (CNBC (article), TradingView (article))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). Tech trails defensives by 15.0 pp over 1M and 2.6 pp over 1W, though it beat them by 0.5 pp on the day.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Headwind: Tech: AI spending doubts (Tech (XLK) vs defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU))
- Headwind: Tech: data-centre policy risk after the midterms (CNBC (article), TradingView (article))
Reasoning
Mechanism: investors doubt the payoff of AI spending → tech, heavy in chips and AI hardware, falls → steady earners in health care, staples and utilities hold up
Key assumptions:
- Tech keeps trailing defensives over 1M: holding
News vs data:
- Coverage tied the chip slump to doubts about AI spending and to state curbs on new data ce: partly consistent (see above)
AI and style themes intact
1. Where we are
Semis have lost their lead: they trail the market by 10.7 pp over 1M and 17.6 pp over 3M, after a 1Y lead that peaked at 84.4 pp in June round-tripped to 20.7 pp on November 5; the 1M lag has re-widened since November 11. State: intact (since 2026-11-05). SMH is 31.2% below its 5-year high; its 90-day gap to the market is −13.4 pp, from −4.8 pp at the end of October.
Path, 1Y (Semiconductors (SMH) vs S&P 500 (SPY)): semis outperforming on 98% of sessions; gap ranged from −3.2 pp (2025-11-21) to +84.4 pp (2026-06-22); largest reversal 63.7 pp, from +84.4 pp on 2026-06-22 to +20.7 pp on 2026-11-05; the last 1W moved the gap −4.3 pp, against its direction; the last 1M moved the gap −18.8 pp, against its direction. Label: volatile / round-trip.
2. How we got here
- 2026-06-22: Semis' 1Y lead over the market peaked at 84.4 pp, the start of the round-trip. (path of Semiconductors (SMH) vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- 2026-10-31: October: semis lagged the market by 13.3 pp. (Semiconductors (SMH) vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- 2026-11-05: The 1Y lead fell to 20.7 pp as the AI trade broke down after the midterms. (path of Semiconductors (SMH) vs S&P 500 (SPY), CNBC (article))
- 2026-11-17: Semis beat the market by 0.6 pp on the day; after the close coverage said Nvidia's blowout numbers eased CEO transition fears. (Semiconductors (SMH) vs S&P 500 (SPY), MarketWatch, 2026-11-18)
Rolling 90-day: SMH minus SPY, trailing 90-day gap: Last −13.4 pp, Oct 31 −4.8 pp, Sep 30 +0.2 pp, Aug 31 −13.2 pp, Jul 31 +2.1 pp, Jun 30 +53.1 pp, May 31 +36.9 pp, Apr 30 +21.4 pp, Mar 31 +10.8 pp, Feb 28 +15.0 pp, Jan 31 +9.7 pp, Dec 31 +4.6 pp, Nov 30 +15.1 pp. All 90-day trends
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
The lag holds over 1W, 1M, 3M and 6M, most of it built in the last month after the round-trip from June's peak; it is accelerating over the month though semis edged ahead on the day.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-10: Broadcom quarterly results (earnings calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
AI spending doubts account for nearly all of the 1M lag, leaving little residual; on the day semis held up better than the market ahead of Nvidia's results.
Today's review: reaffirmed. Both lags hold (10.7 pp over 1M, 17.6 pp over 3M); semis edged ahead on the day before Nvidia's results, which coverage said beat after the close. Confidence: medium. AI doubts are the strongest 1M force, but they faded over the week and semis edged ahead on the day.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- AI spending doubts: steady (Semiconductors (SMH) vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- Data-center policy risk: gone (CNBC (article), TradingView (article))
- Nvidia leadership crisis: gone (CNBC (article), CNBC (article))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). Semis trail the market by 10.7 pp over 1M and 2.5 pp over 1W, though they beat it by 0.6 pp on the day.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Headwind: Semis: AI spending doubts (Semiconductors (SMH) vs S&P 500 (SPY))
Reasoning
Mechanism: investors doubt how long AI hardware spending keeps growing → Democratic wins in data-centre states raise the prospect of curbs on new data centres → chipmakers and AI hardware fall hardest, so semis trail the market
Key assumptions:
- Semis keep trailing the market over 1M: holding
- Semis keep trailing the market over 3M: holding
Other explanations considered:
- Rates hit long-duration chips: The 10Y rose only 1 bp over 1M while semis trail by 10.7 pp, so a rate shock does not fit the month's lag.
News vs data:
- Coverage tied the chip slump to doubts about AI spending and to state curbs on new data ce: partly consistent (see above)
"Nvidia's stock fell 33% from its Oct. 6 peak through Thursday morning." CNBC
AI leaders and QQQ intact
1. Where we are
The AI platform leaders lag the market again: the basket trails by 9.0 pp over 6M and 5.3 pp over 1M, after the 6M gap narrowed to 0.3 pp on October 7 and was rebuilt in the last month. State: intact (since 2026-11-05). The basket is 14.2% below its 5-year high; its 90-day gap to the market is −1.7 pp, from −5.4 pp at the end of October, and 57% of the 6M lag came in the last month.
Path, 6M (AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY)): AI leaders lagging the market on 100% of sessions; gap ranged from −12.2 pp (2026-06-25) to −0.3 pp (2026-10-07); largest reversal 12.0 pp, from −12.2 pp on 2026-06-25 to −0.3 pp on 2026-10-07; 9% of the −9.0 pp gap came in the last 1W; 57% of the −9.0 pp gap came in the last 1M. Label: volatile / round-trip.
2. How we got here
- 2026-06-25: The 6M lag reached 12.2 pp. (path of AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- 2026-10-07: The lag narrowed to 0.3 pp, then reopened. (path of AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- 2026-10-31: October: AI spending outran cash flow at Alphabet and Meta; communication lost 10.0%. (what drove October 2026)
- 2026-11-17: The basket beat the market by 0.6 pp on the day before Nvidia's results; the lag rebuilt since early October holds. (AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY), path of AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY))
Rolling 90-day: AI basket minus SPY, trailing 90-day gap: Last −1.7 pp, Oct 31 −5.4 pp, Sep 30 +9.5 pp, Aug 31 −3.4 pp, Jul 31 −4.1 pp, Jun 30 −2.2 pp, May 31 +9.6 pp, Apr 30 +1.9 pp, Mar 31 −7.0 pp, Feb 28 −9.1 pp, Jan 31 −2.3 pp, Dec 31 +0.9 pp, Nov 30 +5.2 pp. All 90-day trends
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
The 1M and 6M lag, rebuilt in the last month after narrowing in early October, is accelerating over the month, though the basket edged ahead on the day.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
Forward calls. Forward calls are the site's opinion, generated with AI from public data. They are not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Markets are unpredictable and calls are often wrong; see our track record. Do your own research or consult a licensed adviser.
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
The AI platforms keep trailing the S&P 500 over the next month. Direction: underperform; horizon 1M; confidence low; made on 2026-11-05 (call C-2026-11-05-ai-leaders).
AI spending doubts are the only active 1M force and are strengthening, and the election bounce has already reversed. (AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY), CNBC (article))
What would prove it wrong:
- The platforms beat the market over 1M
4. Why it is continuing or turning
AI spending doubts set the 1M lag; the platforms lag less than that force alone implies, so the residual runs in their favour.
Today's review: reaffirmed. The 6M lag holds at 9.0 pp and the call's invalidation did not trigger: the basket trails by 5.3 pp over 1M. Confidence: medium. The 1M and 6M lags agree and AI doubts are the strongest 1M force, though the basket edged ahead on the day.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- AI spending doubts: steady (AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- Policy risk shifting to infrastructure: gone (CNBC (article), TradingView (article))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). The basket trails the market by 5.3 pp over 1M and 1.1 pp over 1W, and by 9.0 pp over 6M, a lag rebuilt in the last month after narrowing in early October.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Headwind: Platforms: AI spending doubts (AI leaders basket vs S&P 500 (SPY))
Reasoning
Mechanism: investors question the payback on the platforms' AI spending → the platforms trail the market over 6M and 1M again, after the 6M lag narrowed in early October → the election bounce reversed as the AI rout spread from chips to the platforms
Key assumptions:
- The platforms still trail the market over 6M: holding
Other explanations considered:
- Policy risk confined to AI infrastructure: The basket trails the market by 5.9 pp over 1M alongside chips, so the platforms were not spared.
News vs data:
- Coverage tied the chip slump to doubts about AI spending and to state curbs on new data ce: partly consistent (see above)
Foreign markets intact
1. Where we are
Emerging markets lag the US: EEM trails the S&P 500 by 3.3 pp over 1M and 9.6 pp over 6M, reversing a 6M lead of 9.0 pp in June; 30% of the 6M gap came in the last month. State: intact (since 2026-06-22). EEM is 18.2% below its 5-year high; its 90-day gap to the US is −7.3 pp, from −6.2 pp at the end of October, and the 6M gap reversed June's lead.
Path, 6M (Emerging (EEM) vs S&P 500 (SPY)): emerging markets behind the US on 65% of sessions; gap ranged from −10.0 pp (2026-11-05) to +9.0 pp (2026-06-22); largest reversal 9.5 pp, from −0.5 pp on 2026-06-05 to +9.0 pp on 2026-06-22; 12% of the −9.6 pp gap came in the last 1W; 30% of the −9.6 pp gap came in the last 1M. Label: volatile / round-trip.
2. How we got here
- 2026-06-22: EEM's 6M lead over the US peaked at 9.0 pp, then reversed. (path of Emerging (EEM) vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- 2026-10-31: October: EEM trailed the US by 7.7 pp. (Emerging (EEM) vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- 2026-11-05: Concerns about AI curbs spilled into Korea and Taiwan. (TradingView (article), path of Emerging (EEM) vs S&P 500 (SPY))
- 2026-11-17: EEM matched the S&P 500's fall on the day; coverage said Japan's October exports beat estimates on chip shipments. (Emerging (EEM) vs S&P 500 (SPY), CNBC (article))
Rolling 90-day: EEM minus SPY, trailing 90-day gap: Last −7.3 pp, Oct 31 −6.2 pp, Sep 30 −1.0 pp, Aug 31 −6.1 pp, Jul 31 −3.5 pp, Jun 30 +5.9 pp, May 31 +1.0 pp, Apr 30 +4.1 pp, Mar 31 +8.2 pp, Feb 28 +16.2 pp, Jan 31 +6.7 pp, Dec 31 +0.4 pp, Nov 30 +2.7 pp. All 90-day trends
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
The lag holds over 1W, 1M and 6M, a 6M gap that reversed June's lead, and it is accelerating.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
The shared forces explain most of the 1M lag, as the chip de-rating hit chip-heavy Asian markets; over 6M, Fed rate-increase pricing adds to it.
Today's review: reaffirmed. EEM still trails the US by 3.3 pp over 1M; the gap was flat on the day. Confidence: low. The 1M and 6M lags agree, but the gap was flat on the day and small over 1W.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- Dollar squeeze: gone (Dollar (UUP ETF))
- Chip de-rating in Asia: gone (TradingView (article), TradingView (article))
- Fed rate-increase pricing: steady (US 2Y)
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). EEM trails the US by 3.3 pp over 1M and 1.5 pp over 1W, and by 9.6 pp over 6M, a gap that reversed June's lead.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Headwind: EM equities: Fed rate-increase pricing (US 2Y)
Reasoning
Mechanism: the AI hardware de-rating hits chip-heavy Asian markets → concerns about AI curbs after the midterms spill into Korea and Taiwan → emerging markets trail the US, while China holds up on support measures
Key assumptions:
- EEM keeps trailing the US over 1M: holding
Crypto intact
1. Where we are
Crypto is out of favour: bitcoin is 48.0% below its 5-year high and down 29.6% over 1Y. State: intact (since 2025-11-04). Bitcoin's 90-day change is −6.4%, down from +21.9% at the end of October, so the summer rebound has gone.
2. How we got here
- 2026-08-31: August: bitcoin beat the S&P 500 by 22.4 pp in a hard-asset trade. (what drove August 2026)
- 2026-10-31: October: bitcoin fell 7.3%. (Bitcoin (USD))
- 2026-11-17: Bitcoin is down 16.2% in November so far, after a 7.3% fall in October. (Bitcoin (USD), what drove November 2026)
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
Down over 1W, 1M, 6M and 1Y, and the pace is accelerating; it steadied on the day.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
Over six months Fed rate-increase pricing and higher real yields weigh on non-yielding, high-beta assets. Over the week the Fed force accounts for much of bitcoin's 12.0% drop.
Today's review: reaffirmed. Bitcoin is down 29.6% over 1Y and 20.3% over 1M; it steadied on the day. Confidence: medium. The 1Y, 1M and 1W declines agree and the Fed force is the only active 1W force.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- Hawkish Fed repricing: steady (US 2Y)
- Real-yield shock: steady (10Y real yield (Treasury))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). Bitcoin fell 12.0% over 1W and 20.3% over 1M; its 90-day change turned negative.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Headwind: Bitcoin: Fed rate-increase pricing (Bitcoin (USD))
- Headwind: Bitcoin: higher real yields (Bitcoin (USD))
Reasoning
Mechanism: markets price Fed rate increases and real yields are higher → non-yielding, high-beta assets lose appeal → bitcoin falls over 1Y and trails stocks
Key assumptions:
- Bitcoin is down over 1Y: holding
News vs data:
- Coverage reported net redemptions from spot bitcoin funds and further bitcoin declines. (cited by BigGo Finance (article), MarketWatch, 2026-11-13) What the data shows (consistent): The data shows bitcoin down 20.3% and Ethereum 24.1% over 1M, in line with the reported fund redemptions.
Commodities shifting
1. Where we are
Oil is priced for a war-driven supply shock: WTI front-month futures are up 43.6% over 1Y. State: shifting (since 2026-10-05). WTI futures are 30.5% below their 5-year high; Brent's 1M fall of 15.2% follows a 3M gain of 2.5%.
Challenger: Crude is losing its war premium: Brent fell 15.2% over 1M and 20.8% in November so far, and energy (XLE) lost 9.5% this month. (since 2026-10-05)
2. How we got here
- 2026-09-30: September: Brent rose 14.4%. (Brent crude (front-month futures))
- 2026-10-31: October: high oil prices lifted energy (XLE) 13.9%. (Energy (XLE), what drove October 2026)
- 2026-11-04: Oil's war premium unwound on hopes of an end to the Iran conflict. (what drove November 2026)
- 2026-11-17: Brent rose 0.76% on the day despite coverage of a supply surplus; it is down 20.8% in November so far. (Brent crude (front-month futures), Reuters, 2026-11-17, what drove November 2026)
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
The 3M rise has nearly gone and crude is down over 1M, but it steadied over the week, so the decline is slowing.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
Over 1Y the oil supply shock carries crude; the 1M drop in commodities is a residual that coverage ties to hopes of an end to the war and easing strike fears.
Today's review: reaffirmed. The challenger still leads: Brent is down 15.2% over 1M, so the state stays shifting. Confidence: low. The 1Y and 1M signals point in opposite directions.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- Iran war supply shock: fading (Brent crude (front-month futures))
- Pressure to end the war: steady (TradingView (article), TradingNEWS (article))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). Brent rose 1.8% over 1W after falling 15.2% over 1M; its 3M gain is down to 2.5%.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Tailwind: Crude: the Iran war supply shock (WTI crude (front-month futures))
- Headwind: Crude: hopes of an end to the Iran war (TradingView (article), TradingNEWS (article))
Reasoning
Mechanism: the Iran war restricts crude supply → crude is up sharply over 1Y → easing strike fears and hopes of an end to the war now pull crude back
Key assumptions:
- Brent keeps falling over 1M: holding
Other explanations considered:
- Weaker demand: Copper beat gold by 6.2 pp on a 90-day basis while crude fell, which fits a fading supply premium better than a demand slump.
News vs data:
- Coverage linked the drop in oil to hopes of an end to the Iran war after the midterms and to a supply surplus. (cited by TradingView (article), Reuters, 2026-11-17, Reuters, 2026-11-18) What the data shows (consistent): The data shows Brent down 15.2%, commodities (DBC) 10.5% and energy (XLE) 7.2% over 1M, a move the monthly loop ties to the unwinding war premium.
Rates intact
1. Where we are
Higher for longer: the market prices more Fed increases, with the 2Y up 120 bp over 1Y and Kalshi odds of 95.5% for a December increase. State: intact (since 2026-11-10). The 2Y's 90-day change is +61 bp, up from +28 bp at the end of October; Kalshi odds put the upper bound at 4.57% after the April 2027 meeting, from 4.00% now.
2. How we got here
- 2026-09-30: September: the Fed's first hike since 2023 lifted short rates and long yields. (what drove September 2026, US 10Y)
- 2026-10-31: October: the 10Y fell 0.35 pp. (US 10Y)
- 2026-11-10: October consumer prices rose above estimates after Fed Governor Waller opened the door to a half-point increase. (CNBC (article), Federal Reserve (article))
- 2026-11-17: St. Louis Fed President Musalem said up to four more increases may be needed; Kalshi odds of a December increase rose to 95.5%. (CNBC (article))
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
Short and long yields rose over 1W and the 10Y's pace is accelerating, though both slipped on the day as stocks fell.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
Hawkish Fed repricing holds yields up from 1W to 1Y, and the real-yield shock adds over 6M; easing inflation pressure pulls long yields the other way over 6M, and growth fear over 3M.
Today's review: strengthened. Both assumptions hold; Musalem called for up to four more increases and Kalshi odds of a December increase rose to 95.5%. Confidence: high. The 2Y, the real yield and Kalshi odds of a December increase all rose over the week, and the Fed force is the only active 1W force.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- Hawkish Fed repricing: steady (US 2Y)
- Inflation pressure easing: strengthening (10Y breakeven (nominal minus real yield))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). The 10Y rose 12 bp over 1W, 1 bp over 1M and 97 bp over 1Y; it fell 2 bp on the day.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Tailwind: Higher yields: Fed rate-increase pricing (US 2Y)
- Tailwind: Higher yields: higher real yields (10Y real yield (Treasury))
- Headwind: Higher yields: easing inflation pressure (10Y breakeven (nominal minus real yield))
- Headwind: Higher yields: growth fear (Cyclicals (XLY, XLF, XLI, XLB) vs defensives (XLP, XLV, XLU))
Reasoning
Mechanism: inflation runs above the Fed's goal and October prices rose above estimates → Fed officials signal further increases and markets price them → short yields rise well above their level a year ago
Key assumptions:
- The 2Y yield is above its level a year ago: holding
- The 2Y keeps rising over 1W: holding
Other explanations considered:
- A growth scare: The 2Y rose 27 bp over the week while havens were sold, which fits rate-increase pricing rather than a growth scare.
News vs data:
- Coverage said markets priced more Fed increases, with St. Louis Fed President Musalem calling for up to four more and the dollar's rally erasing its 'liberation day' losses. (cited by CNBC (article), Financial Times, 2026-11-17, CNBC (article)) What the data shows (consistent): The data shows the 2Y up 7 bp, the real yield up 11 bp and the dollar up 1.3% over the week, and the fitted Fed force is the only active 1W force.
"The economy will likely require several interest rate increases before the spring of 2027" CNBC
- Coverage said St. Louis Fed President Musalem called for up to four more Fed increases. (cited by CNBC (article), CNBC, 2026-11-17) What the data shows (not consistent): The data shows the 2Y down 3 bp and the dollar down 0.07% on the day as stocks fell, and no shared force is active over two sessions; the call fits the week's repricing rather than the day.
"the central bank may need to hike its benchmark rate as many as four times by early next year." CNBC
Credit intact
1. Where we are
Credit is calm: high yield leads IG by 0.5 pp over 1M, and regional banks have regained their lead, beating the market by 5.5 pp over 1M. State: intact (since 2026-05-04). HYG is 2.7% below its 5-year high; its 90-day gap to IG is 0.0 pp, from −0.5 pp at the end of October.
Path, 1M (High yield (HYG) vs IG corporate (LQD)): high yield ahead of IG (risk appetite) on 55% of sessions; gap ranged from −0.5 pp (2026-10-22) to +0.8 pp (2026-11-13); largest reversal 1.0 pp, from +0.5 pp on 2026-10-19 to −0.5 pp on 2026-10-22; 81% of the +0.5 pp gap came in the last 1W. Label: steady.
Path, 1M (Regional banks (KRE) vs S&P 500 (SPY)): regional banks ahead on 91% of sessions; gap ranged from −1.2 pp (2026-10-19) to +7.5 pp (2026-11-05); largest reversal 2.9 pp, from +7.5 pp on 2026-11-05 to +4.7 pp on 2026-11-12; the last 1W moved the gap −0.9 pp, against its direction. Label: volatile / round-trip.
Path, 1M (High yield (HYG) vs IG corporate (LQD)): high yield ahead of IG on 55% of sessions; gap ranged from −0.5 pp (2026-10-22) to +0.8 pp (2026-11-13); largest reversal 1.0 pp, from +0.5 pp on 2026-10-19 to −0.5 pp on 2026-10-22; 81% of the +0.5 pp gap came in the last 1W. Label: steady.
2. How we got here
- 2026-09-30: September: high yield lost 2.7% in a rate shock with wider spreads. (what drove September 2026)
- 2026-10-31: October: high yield trailed IG by 1.8 pp. (High yield (HYG) vs IG corporate (LQD))
- 2026-11-17: HYG fell 0.7% over the week as yields rose, yet beat IG by 0.4 pp. (High yield (HYG) vs IG corporate (LQD), High yield (HYG))
Rolling 90-day: HYG minus LQD, trailing 90-day gap: Last 0.0 pp, Oct 31 −0.5 pp, Sep 30 +3.0 pp, Aug 31 +2.6 pp, Jul 31 +1.7 pp, Jun 30 +0.6 pp, May 31 +1.7 pp, Apr 30 +1.0 pp, Mar 31 0.0 pp, Feb 28 +0.1 pp, Jan 31 +1.3 pp, Dec 31 +1.3 pp, Nov 30 −1.4 pp. All 90-day trends
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
High yield leads IG over 1W and 1M by small margins and the pace is accelerating, though it trailed slightly on the day.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
The small 1M lead of high yield fits the shared forces, with little residual; money growth keeps the longer-run backdrop calm.
Today's review: reaffirmed. High yield gained 0.2% over 1M and still leads IG. Confidence: medium. Credit held up through the AI slump and the rate jump.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- Risk appetite: gone (High yield (HYG) vs IG corporate (LQD))
- Debt-ceiling coverage: gone (CNBC (article), CNBC (article))
- AI-related borrowing: gone (BigGo Finance (article), Federal Reserve, 2026-11-16)
- Plentiful money: steady (liquidity metrics)
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). High yield leads IG by 0.5 pp over 1M and 0.4 pp over 1W, and trailed by 0.1 pp on the day.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Tailwind: High yield: plentiful money (liquidity metrics)
Reasoning
Mechanism: money growth keeps funding plentiful → credit spreads stay contained → high yield holds up as rising yields hit longer-duration IG bonds harder
Key assumptions:
- High yield gains over 1M: holding
Dollar and volatility intact
1. Where we are
The dollar is firm on Fed rate-increase pricing: UUP is up 8.4% over 1Y and sits 0.1% below its 5-year high. State: intact (since 2025-11-04). UUP is 0.1% below its 5-year high; its 90-day change is +6.0%, up from +2.9% at the end of October.
2. How we got here
- 2026-09-30: September: UUP rose 2.3% with the Fed's hike. (Dollar (UUP ETF), what drove September 2026)
- 2026-10-31: October: UUP rose 0.8%. (Dollar (UUP ETF))
- 2026-11-06: The jobs report lifted Fed rate-increase pricing and UUP reached a 5-year high. (Dollar (UUP ETF), CNBC (article))
- 2026-11-17: Coverage said the dollar's rally erased its 'liberation day' losses as markets priced more rate increases; the VIX rose 11.13% to 25.46. (Financial Times, 2026-11-17, VIX (Cboe))
3. Direction of travel (not a forecast)
The dollar is up over 1W, 1M, 3M, 6M and 1Y, and the pace is accelerating.
Upcoming events that bear on this:
- 2026-12-09: FOMC decision (Federal Reserve calendar)
3b. Where we're heading (our call)
No open call. Track record for this asset: no closed calls yet. All calls
4. Why it is continuing or turning
Over 1Y hawkish Fed repricing and higher real yields support the dollar; over the week the Fed force, the only active 1W force, lifted it further.
Today's review: reaffirmed. The dollar is up 8.4% over 1Y and 2.1% over 1M; it slipped 0.07% on the day. Confidence: high. The dollar is up on every horizon from 1W to 1Y and rate-increase pricing firmed over the week.
5. Are the driving forces changing?
- Hawkish Fed repricing: steady (Dollar (UUP ETF))
- Real-yield shock: steady (10Y real yield (Treasury))
6. Speed
accelerating (computed from the pace of change per trading day). UUP is up 8.4% over 1Y, 5.1% over 3M and 1.3% over 1W.
7. Tailwinds and headwinds
- Tailwind: Dollar: Fed rate-increase pricing (Dollar (UUP ETF))
- Tailwind: Dollar: higher real yields (10Y real yield (Treasury))
Reasoning
Mechanism: markets price Fed rate increases → US real yields are higher than abroad → the dollar gains over 1Y
Key assumptions:
- The dollar is up over 1Y: holding
Not investment advice. MarketMoves describes past market data and reported news for general information. Figures can be delayed or wrong; check the original source before relying on them.